The Harvard Advocate - America's Oldest College Literary Magazine


▶ We mourn the passing of Advocate trustee Charlie Atkinson.




MOGU — When life gives you lemons, eat mushrooms.Boston Philharmonic Youth Orchestra — Benjamin Zander, Conductor. Sunday May 3, 7:00 PM, Symphony Hall, Boston. Tickets from $25, Students $12.
The Harvard Advocate sanctum, with a musician playing to a small crowd.


The fresh online pieces we experiment with outside of our print cycle. Formerly known as Blog.

Notes


February 14, 2026

E. E. Cummings - “[up into the silence the green]”

Honestly, if you have time to read this blurb, you have time to read the poem. Read the poem. —Anika Hatzius



Text: pics from 21 south street
The Harvard Advocate Instagram post
The Harvard Advocate Instagram post
The Harvard Advocate Instagram post
Boston Philharmonic Youth Orchestra — Benjamin Zander, Conductor. Sunday May 3, 7:00 PM, Symphony Hall, Boston.

From the Archives


Features Winter 2016 - Danger


I was out of shape when I showed up. I had kind of thought I was done. I had already made it through the hoop that counted, the admissions hoop. I had stuck my landing; now I could relax. They don’t tell you when they accept you that hoop-jumping is the official sport of the College. Especially at the beginning, I had this sense that I was in fact a hoop-jumping recruit, a scholarship kid. I had to keep jumping to earn my spot here. I would later talk about the sport in terms of the fix: that dopamine rush as your toes have cleared and you realize *you’re through*.  In those first monthswe were all obsessed with recreating the experience of that first successful jump.



 



You get the sense that you have to join a cult to make it here. There are a lot of options for what cult to join, but you have to join *one* or you’re never gonna have a Real College Experience. Unless you have really great roommates. If you have really great roommates, you’re exempt.



 



To join a cult, you have to jump through that cult’s hoop. When you meet people here, you look at their bodies. You look at what muscles they have where, whether it looks like they could make a particular jump.



 



The cults recruit every semester. They run training programs that last most of the semester and culminate with the Jump where you either make it through the hoop and into the cult or you don’t. Sometimes there is a preliminary hoop that happens halfway through training, and if you don’t make it, you aren’t allowed to try to make it through the final hoop that semester. Every cult has its own hoop—different shapes, different heights—and each training program is tailored specifically to the cult’s hoop. Sometimes training for one can make it very hard for your muscles to learn to jump through a different one. Some hoops are easier for certain body types.



 



It’s a big deal. At the very end of College there’s always the prestigious Hoops prize which I think is for the senior who has jumped through the most hoops. If you get that you can do whatever you want. Then you definitely don’t have to jump through any more hoops.



 



       I knew pretty early on which cult I wanted to try out for. I went to the Intro Training meeting. I was shaking a little bit when I walked into the culthouse—it felt important and intimidating, like the very wood was charged with gravitas. I looked at all the older affiliates and thought they looked much cooler than me. They were sitting around a heavy wooden table, with the Big Kahunas sitting in the middle looking important, looking out at us. All the jumpers were on the floor. All the affiliates spoke with the same cadence. Perhaps they spent so much time around each other that one had adopted another’s distinct manner of speaking in turn until everyone spoke with the same unified nuances. This was true of a lot of the cults: You could tell who was in what by how their voice sounded. All these affiliates made it through the hoop, I thought to myself. This terrified me. I imagined their bodies tensing up with nerves, sprinting and vaulting and *clearing the hoop*, muscles taut. I imagined the smiles on their faces when they stuck the landing. Some of their bodies had since gone to seed. Once you made it through the hoop, I guessed, you didn’t really have to stay in shape. You didn’t have to worry about much at all: In a cult, you had it made. People *respected *you.



 



       At the training meeting, we watched all the old videos, in which famous old affiliates, long graduated, cleared the cult hoop with *style*. I felt my toes pointing in my boots. I was anxious to prove myself. I was on *fire *with it. At the end of the meeting, the Big Kahunas looked at each other and took the big group of us jumpers into a small locked room in the basement of the culthouse. We were all huddled in the doorway—I went up on my tiptoes to see over the group in front of me. And there it was.



 



       “Of course, it will be higher,” said the Big Kahuna. It was old and made of a warm brassy medal and extensively engraved. It was a small hoop—not more than three feet in diameter—but I heard they kept it relatively low down. This was good, because I was not very tall. It seemed like it would weigh a lot and hurt a lot if you messed up your jump and crashed into it. I looked back at the other jumpers. They were all shiny-eyed. Some of them were already in very good hoop-shape. I was going to have to train very hard, but I really wanted it.



 



       I spent long hours doing the calisthenics the cult’s trainer recommended.



 



There are rumors that affiliates lower the hoop for jumpers they like, for jumpers who look like they would belong in the cult. I didn’t know whether to believe them or not, so I tried to dress like the affiliates and try to get the cult trainer to like me, just in case it helps. I got to know some of the other jumpers during our training sessions and we would laugh in hushed voices about the vocal tics of the cult trainer or the Big Kahunas’ pretensions during the Intro Training meeting. I felt connected to these other jumpers.



 



A couple days before the preliminary hoop, I cried over lunch with an older friend who had cleared a number of well-respected hoops. Sometimes around here it feels like everything's about who's jumped through what hoops. I asked why we even needed cults. If there were no cults, I told him, we could just*spend time together *and get to know each other in the normal way and not spend our time sniffing out who was worth knowing based on what cult they were in. He nodded patiently and told me that all of these things had occurred to him when he was a young jumper. This complacency made me terribly angry: Once you were enfranchised, once you were in, there was obviously no motivation to do anything about it. I imagined myself, suddenly, years down the line, a complacent affiliate, watching all these freshmen making the jump they’d trained for months for and missing the hoop and knowing they would spend another semester on the outside. Don’t let me be that person, I told myself. A small voice said, *But if you make it, of course you will be.  *



 



       I made it through the preliminary hoop, which was just like the final one but larger, easier, made of a flimsier and more forgiving material, and kept training hard. I watched my body change. I woke up to aching muscles I didn’t know I had. I dreamed about that final hoop. There it was, dusty, winking at me from the basement of the culthouse.



 



Final hoop day was less of a big deal than I thought it would be: They hauled the thing up into the big main room on the second floor of the culthouse and you waited in line until it was your turn to jump. You made it through or you didn’t, and then you landed.



 



When you're looking at a hoop—even a low hoop, even a hoop that everyone makes it through eventually—you're thinking a couple of thoughts. You're thinking that this hoop is the measure of your worth as an individual. You *know *that this isn’t true—you know that there’s a lot of chance and variables you can’t control that go into whether you make it or not—but you inadvertently can color the result as the ultimate reflection on your innermost self. Do I deserve this, you’re thinking, or you’re not, because you’re focusing too hard on the jump itself.



 



I made it, and I stuck my landing, thank god. The cult trainer and a couple of other affiliates marked notes on clipboards. A Kahuna carefully measured my final distance from the hoop, which was discouragingly small. Other jumpers had jumped further. There was some polite applause, and I was ushered into a room downstairs to wait with the other jumpers who had made it.



 



Because I was a freshman the cult swallowed me pretty cleanly—I didn’t have many strong attachments. After I became an affiliate of my cult, I saw those other jumpers—the ones I’d gotten to know who hadn’t make it—around the College. They didn’t really want to talk to me. It was okay: Suddenly I had a place to go, somewhere I felt a little bit special every time I walked in the door. The culthouse felt like it was a place of magic. It radiated out from the hoop stored in the basement, permeating everything we did and said inside the culthouse. I felt lucky to be a part of all of it.



 



A week or so after I made it through the hoop, a Big Kahuna mused that he was jealous: He wished he could be a new affiliate again. I stared at him, wide-eyed, and asked why he’d ever want that. Big Kahuna smiled and said that as a new affiliate, everything felt so magical and shiny and new. Over time, he said, with more responsibility, the magic wears out. I have a song for you, he said, and hooked up his phone to the speakers to play a song which repeated a single lyric to an infuriating beat. “You can normalize,” a voice said over the sound system, “Don’t it make you feel alive?”



 



I thought about that glowing hoop in the basement. I couldn’t imagine normalizing any of this.  We have this notion that we can reach out and grab the self-assurance of affiliation and hold onto it forever. Really we can only take validation in doses. The feeling always fades, and then you need a little more. You find yourself another hoop, but there are always diminishing returns: Suddenly the same dosage won’t do it for you anymore. It’s like when you get stronger and suddenly the ten pound weight doesn’t make your muscles burn. You get something heavier. It seemed like if you wanted to feel like a real part of the cult, you had to be a Kahuna.



 



Becoming a Kahuna meant another jump—this time through the separate intracult hoop, which was a different deal entirely. This one was very large but was some kind of a polygon, a scalene triangle, they said, so it would be easy to guess the angle wrong and get stuck. The Kahuna hoop was set out annually and the jump was set to happen about a month after I became an affiliate. Luckily for new affiliates they kept the hoop pretty low. (It was higher, of course, if you wanted to be a Bigger Kahuna). I was still in good jumping shape and made it right through.



 



As a little Kahuna, I had new responsibilities.



 



I could play my own music over the speakers in the culthouse. Suddenly I couldn’t hear the different cadence in the voices of the Big Kahunas and couldn’t tell if I’d adopted it or not—it just felt normal. At first, cult-ural acclimation is confusing and weird and stilted, and then it’s natural, and then it’s just like breathing, and then you can’t imagine *not *doing those things. You can’t remember a time when you didn’t know to play this song or drink that drink. I *was *starting to normalize. There is something really satisfying about feeling like a part of a place just by knowing its little customs.



 



But that humming golden hoop in the basement just felt like an old hump of metal. For so long I had felt I was catching a glimpse of something furtive and beautiful that belonged to all of us, partaking in a set of customs and aesthetics decided by a Big Kahuna long ago. Now, another little Kahuna and I would play a certain song and then someone would ask for that same song a couple days later. We could do things that had never been done before, and affiliates might like them, affiliates might do them with us.



 



This was exciting, but it was also hard to be in awe of something we were making. I wanted that reverie back.



 



Suddenly I was on the other side of the Intro Training meeting. I was very conscious of this reversal, but it didn’t really feel like a big deal. It felt hollower from the other side: The affiliates at the table were all familiar faces. I wondered if we seemed intimidating and cool to the jumpers. I couldn’t imagine we did. We were just goons.



 



I was put in charge of training a couple of jumpers that Spring. I turned to older affiliates for training programs and held as many extra practice sessions as my jumpers wanted. I cared about them. Not one of my jumpers made it.



 



And then there are the would-be affiliates who were told from a young age that hoop-jumping isn't for them. Their bodies weren't built to jump through hoops, affiliates used to think. Moreover, maybe the hoops weren't made to allow their bodies through. This is a complicated problem which can't always be solved by changing the shape of the hoop (the shape of each cult's hoop is sacred, so sacred). From the inside, I badly wanted to believe that mystique and inclusivity were not mutually exclusive.



 



At the College, the absence of a cult can feel like a deep insecurity that leaves you open to a kind of death: the death of being just like everyone else. Or at the very least, it’s like being the only vegetarian at a BBQ restaurant or the non-smoker on the smoke break, except instead of cigarettes we’re talking about achievement-crack. I admire these people who do the College without it.



 



Sometimes I worry that one day I will be old with all of the spoils of my hoop-jumping career sitting around me and wish I had spent my life on something other than the stupid sport. I consider the arthritis some long-term hoop-jumpers get from the repeated exertion. I’ve already had one bout of this arthritis.



 



But the spoils can be sweet: the feeling of communal self-worth; a kind of special inclusion in something magical and secret; a humbling sense of one’s own privilege to be a part of the group. I think some of it also really does come from all those good things we talk about in our pre-jump speeches: from having a community in which to invest your energies, a thing you have come to care about altruistically, for its own sake. The big old world, from inside of a cult, was whittled to a manageable size.



 



I don’t think they’re mutually exclusive—the community-mindedness and the validation —but I worry that the latter is addictive.



 



I decide to go for a bigger hoop. A lot of people expect that I’ll have no trouble making it through—I’ve never missed, have I? I’ve done a lot for the cult and the Big Kahunas will recognize that and put the hoop lower.



 



I don't make it through the hoop. A tie on my jacket gets caught on one of the odd polygon’s corners and I hang there, half in half out, for much too long before they figure out how to get me down.



 



       People normally don't get stuck. When they take me down, everyone’s sympathetic. It’s okay, they tell me. We’re still your family.



 



The other little Kahuna makes it through and becomes a Big Kahuna. I feel a little bit left behind, and then again, I’m happy for him. I’m happy for the cult; I know he’ll do great things as a Big Kahuna. But I’m sad that I won’t get to do them with him. I didn’t know how to look at this: The cult was in great hands, but those hands weren’t my hands. It didn’t need me.



 



These things are really fucking messy psychological experiences. They never sound good politically: In this article, I inevitably come across as overly ambitious or a traitor to my cult or allegiant to a problematic power structure. We talk about all this in such sanitized terms: Are cults objectively *good*, or objectively *bad*, for the College community as a whole? I think the real answer is much more nuanced—the structure as it is has oscillated between giving me a home and a sense of magic and breaking hearts (mine, others’). My time as a jumper and then as an affiliate and then as a Kahuna—an absurd trajectory which is completely illegible outside of the College—has given some meaning to my subjective and individual experience. I think there are conversations about these groups that aren’t making it into the discourse (the politically-incorrect, subjective, biased experiences of people inside and out, which get sterilized into strong political statements). I think we too often conflate ambivalent subjectivity with emptiness, uselessness.



 



Let’s end with a tally. I have gratitude for the strength I gained from jumps, successful and not, and gratitude for the family the hoop gave me. I worry about the way that love for the sport itself can tear this family apart. I worry about cult-ures of exclusivity and the lines (perhaps arbitrary) they draw between the inside and the outside. We dance across these lines (which make all of us uncomfortable, inside or out) with buzzwords like “inclusivity” and scathing op-eds and small acts of kindness toward our hoop-trainees. I think there are fulfilling ways to be in and around this cult-ure without hoop addiction. I am still trying to find them.



Features Commencement 2013


*“I can assure you, there is no panic, no fear, no despair in London town.”

**                            **London Can Take It!*, 1940



    “There are terrorists in London.”

    Two Bengali Muslim girls in my class told me this. I laughed. No there weren’t. These girls were always making things up: that Lianna in 8C was pregnant, that our mild-mannered geography teacher had pinched a girl’s bum.

    Even now, they were laughing with me. But something in their giggles was sour. Nervously, one of them pushed onto my desk an article from BBC News, still warm from the library printer.

    “Innit?”

    Innit might be the most frequently spoken word in British slang. It can mean both “isn’t it?” and “it is,” depending on the tone, and therefore has a kind of limitless use. Unsurprisingly, it is young people who say it the most: we who want nothing more than to be approved of, to be in agreement. *Innit? Innit.

*    I looked for signs that the article was a spoof, a prank. There was the BBC logo. The correct date and time. The pictures of ambulances, smoke, panic. The number 30 bus. The Circle line.

    We tried to get our religious studies teacher to acknowledge what was going on. Her cheeks turned red. Yes, something had happened, but it was going to be all right and we were going to continue with the class. This was 2005, two years prior to the release of the first iPhone. We sat there lamely, taking turns to read that one BBC article over and over again. In the background, our teacher lectured on Sikhism.



   * **“London looks upwards towards the dawn and faces the new day with calmness and confidence.”*



    The day after the bombs, all of London was back on the buses and tubes. That’s how the story went, anyway, the one that the politicians told the world—and it wasn’t exactly untrue. On the train I took every day, the 8:12 to Camden Road, I counted off the faces. The white businessman with his copy of the Financial Times: still there. The Serbian schoolgirls in their hideous plaid uniforms: I could hear them in the other carriage. The young professional-looking woman in a hijab with her eyes closed, always listening to her MP3 player: leaning against a window. The old black man in stained clothing who sang to us softly about Jesus: he was there, too. Everyone a different color, everyone’s gaze pointed in a different direction, back on the train that was ours.







*    “London manages to get to work on time, one way or another.”*



    A terrorist attack in a certain place turns all who use that space into potential targets. In hindsight, any of us might have been the intended victims, something we made sure not to forget.

    “I got the Circle line last week at exactly ten minutes to nine.”

    “My dad’s office is a five-minute walk from Tavistock Square.”

    “The 30 goes right outside my house.”

    Almost no member of British society is above riding public transportation. Even the Queen took a spin on the Jubilee line when it first opened. And I have never encountered another city as willing as London to symbolize itself as a subway map.



*    “London is fighting back.”*



 



    In 1940, in the fifth week of the Blitz, the British government produced a nine-minute propaganda movie entitled *London Can Take It!* that was distributed across the UK and US. It begins with scenes of Londoners commuting home from work during rush hour: boarding buses, descending into subway stations, crossing a bridge over the Thames on foot. The narrator describes them as “the greatest civilian army ever to have been assembled.” The film makes other similarly grandiose declarations about London and its citizens. According to the narrator, London is free of panic and despair: there is only “calmness and confidence.” At night, the people sleep fearlessly as the bombs bring their city to the ground.

    Sixty-five years later, the UK government partnered with advertising firms, newspapers, and other private corporations to create an enormous post-7/7 media campaign that ended up costing over three million pounds, called “7 Million Londoners, 1 London.” The idea consisted of a single logo: the phrase “7 Million Londoners,” with the words “1 London” highlighted within it in a different color.

    “London is an urban, multicultural community,” London’s then-mayor, Ken Livingstone, stated in his endorsement of the 7 Million campaign. Straying from the nationalist rhetoric of the Prime Minister, Tony Blair, he noted that the campaign was important because it celebrated “the principle of difference rather than unity.”

    And yet, there were those words—“One London”—etched in an uncompromising bright red. Later, the campaign added another phrase, sealing its promotion of cosmopolitan unity: “We Are Londoners, We Are One.” Any Londoner could order a poster, badge, or window sticker inscribed with either of these slogans for free. “7 Million” banners lined every major street; billboard-sized posters could be found on the side of most buses and on the walls of every tube station.

    The campaign underlined a narrative that was already circulating in media and politics on both sides of the Atlantic. Londoners were being described as inherently tough and resilient. Our decision to ride public transportation the day after the attacks was “courageous.” Politicians worldwide praised the city for its “business as usual” approach to a post-7/7 world. Few failed to claim that London’s reaction to the attacks was demonstrative of an attitude of stoicism and defiance that we had all somehow collectively inherited from the Blitz.

    “We survived the Blitz. We lived through 30 years of IRA outrages...” The British tabloid *The Daily Mirror* reminded its readers. “Once again the British people will triumph over evil.”



    *“Do you see any signs of fear on these faces?”*



* *    In the weeks following July 7th, the fact that all four of the suicide bombers were English, or had at least grown up in England, grew awkwardly prominent. Three out of four had been second-generation British citizens, born and raised in Leeds, in the north of the country. None of them were known to the authorities before the attacks. Three were of Pakistani descent; in many of London’s boroughs, the population is around 10% Pakistani. One was Jamaican, as are so many Londoners whose families have emigrated to the UK since the beginning of the Empire Windrush in 1948.

    This wasn’t the Blitz, then; it wasn’t possible to speak of “the Germans” who wanted to kill us, nor to anthropomorphize every bomb that dropped as a manifestation of Hitler’s villainous wrath. These were men who worked in the primary schools that our children attended and prayed at the same mosques as we did and had sat next to us on tubes and buses many times before without ever having blown us up.

    Was there any “One London” united by a desire to preserve our city and “triumph over evil”? London has 7 million inhabitants, which, in the months and years following 7/7, amounted to 7 million suspicious glances. 7 million reasons to get off and wait for the next train. 7 million sharp intakes of breath as someone who didn’t look quite right boarded the bus. The one out of 7 million chance that you, an unassuming 27-year-old Brazilian Catholic man, would be murdered by the police as you tried to get on the tube at Stockwell station.

    A few weeks after the bombs went off, a Muslim Londoner was interviewed on the radio about his experience following 7/7.

    “Well, I take a bottle of wine with me and hold it on my lap when I go on the tube. So people don’t think I’m a fundamentalist.”

    “Do you drink alcohol?” the radio host asked.

    “Of course not,” the man replied quickly. “I’m a Muslim.”



 



*    “Today the morale of the people is higher than ever before.”*



 



    In London, as in countless other cities around the world, we live with the reality that the next attack is coming. For all their praise of our resilience, no politician nor journalist nor news anchor can assure us that there won’t be more bombs, more chaos, more buses with roofs that are blown off through the air. More suspicion, more racism, more accidental deaths of the innocent in a panicked rush to defeat what we don’t fully understand.



    There are terrorists in London.



Fiction Commencement 2009


 



I



              That night, as they did regularly on Friday evenings, James and Elizabeth made love before going to sleep.



              Their bedroom, which Elizabeth had done up, was timidly, tastefully decorated.  Next to the window that faced the bed hung a reproduction of a Van Gogh which Elizabeth had purchased after an exhibition at the Museum of Fine Arts.  Next to it, in silver frames, their son Adam’s grammar-school efforts were arranged vertically, and a photograph of Adam standing naked with a wiffle bat in his hand stood on James’s dresser.  There was a fire place, seldom used, and an electric heater because Elizabeth was frequently cold at night.  James kept a night table next to the bed, in which were birthday cards from Adam, old batteries, scraps of paper on which he sometimes wrote down his dreams (“Dad slips on the ice and I just let him fall”), and all of the other indicators a man accumulates which show what he has done and what he has failed to do.  



              Atop the nightstand was James’s bedside light.  He switched it off.  Now the room was quiet, dark, the bed inviting and warm.  Wordlessly he reached his arm across under the covers, where he knew her body would be waiting for his fingers, his hands, his legs and belly and cock.  For this was the baffling wing which kept their marriage aloft—the outboard motor that growled them to harbor each night when sails ripped: no matter what happened during the day, they were in one another’s arms each night with the same passion.  Of course he had desired younger women—what man his age hadn’t?—and he had, it was true, sometimes fantasized about his patients.  But not the way he desired Elizabeth.  And now, with his hot hands cupping her breasts and his lips against the soft, cool skin of her cheek, he was reminded once again of the complexity of the whole situation.  That, and how much he looked forward to the sex, complexity be damned.



              Gently, skillfully, he kissed down her neck.  Did he think about how her body used to be, these evenings when they lay together, a man of 66 and a woman of 55, and made love?  How could he avoid remembering?  And it was true: he readily made pictures in his mind of his wife’s younger body, the harder belly, firmer breasts and lighter-colored nipples, the wetness between her legs which had come sooner and more completely.  Yet he forced himself to be reasonable.  His own body no longer worked in the efficient, forceful way that it had when he was young.  That was what happened: age set in like a hard, hard frost.  You watched yourself get colder and weaker, watched your once-strong limbs wrinkle and lose their agility, were kicked and beaten like a dog, until finally, towards the end, just when you couldn’t believe it would get any worse, any less bearable, it did: and that was death.  Boom.  Just like that.



              “Lizzie,” he said.  “Have you been waiting for me to come to bed?”



              “I may have been,” she said.  “I may have gone to sleep if you hadn’t come in when you did.”  They both laughed.  All of the things that were ponderously difficult in daylight -- teasing, competing, being vulnerable -- were pure ease when they were in bed together.  Sex was easy between them.



              “Is that so?  I guess you really make the rules around here,” he said.



              “Mmmm,” she murmured, and then she took him in her hand.  Rather than hurry, as they had when they were younger, James and Elizabeth made love with dilatory patience, they had learned to enjoy the details of each other’s bodies, even though, James thought, their bodies were fast becoming flabby-assed and worthless.  How nice it felt to slip himself uncovered into his wife of 28 years!  They made love traditionally, with Elizabeth lying on her back and he on top of her.  That way, there were no decisions to be made when they went to bed.  She pressed her body into his, and with her hands she worked the skin of his back.  When he bent his head to lick the impression between her collarbones, he tasted salt, and he could smell his own smell, too, coming from underneath his arms, when he turned his head, and he liked it—the salt and the sweat—because, well, he wasn’t certain why.  As a boy, in the schools he attended near his father’s air force bases, he would bathe himself meticulously; he was not one of the boys, even at nine or ten years old, who had to be reprimanded for failing to clean behind his ears.  (In fact, he liked it—in the whirling sequence of homes and schools that had made of his boyhood an endless learning and relearning, it had been his body, his own, compact body, which had come to be consistent and familiar.  Perhaps this was why, when he showered, he never deviated from his washing routine.)  Elizabeth made a wonderful, whimpering sound; he spoke her name.



              Sweat.  The smell of it, the feeling of it.  Flag football outside bases in Virginia, Colorado, the hot wind cold against his damp face as he rode his bicycle through blooming, fragrant fields in optimistic martial towns.  Again he brought his lips to her throat, and again the saltiness exhilarated him.  They began to crush into one another quicker and more closely, until, without warning, he felt the familiar feeling, the atavistic whorl in his belly which told him that it was about to be over.  “Lizzie,” he said.  Begging, ragged hat in eager hand, his body shivered against hers.  It was happening, he could feel it, and he could feel her own orgasm gathering itself together like summer wind whipping at hot air.  Here it came again, that knock-out sound!



              As a young woman, she had come self-consciously, as though surprised by the way her body responded to his.  Now she was older, the shame didn’t matter.  And god, that sound, that sound.  The whorl in his belly tightened, until, finally, it raveled unbearably and, just as quickly, unraveled; everything ran out of him.  A moment later, Elizabeth drew her breath deep into her lungs, cried out, and fell back against the bed, her muscles loosened and her eyes closed.  “Oh, baby doll,” he said.



              In the bathroom afterwards, washing his face and fixing his pajamas, he felt in his hands a kind of blood-spun throb.  Again they were no longer the hands of an old man, but the powerful implements of a youth, filled and animated with marvelous liquid from his old, pathetic heart.



 



              One week later he was diagnosed with prostate cancer.  He received a call from Adam, who sounded concerned.



              “Champ!”



              “Hi, Dad,” said Adam.



              “So.  Mom told you what’s happening?  My goddamn prostate is eating me alive.”  



              “What are you talking about?  When did you find this out?”



              “I went in for a PSA last Thursday, because my cardiologist recommended it.  I am sixty-six, you see, so I am at elevated risk.  Now the cardiologist, having nothing to do with my prostate, did some blood work, and the PSA came back higher than it ought to be.  Four days later, here I am.  They’re doing another blood work-up, then I have an MRI this afternoon.  Dr. Blumenthal says he should know by Wednesday morning whether it’s wise to operate.  He said it doesn’t seem to have spread, so a short surgery should take care of it.”



              Adam knew his father’s medical history as a cautionary tale against which doctors annually compared the workings of his own body.  But in crisis his father always chose the most clinical language possible, which led Adam to feel, when James talked about his heart problems or, now, a high PSA, as though they weren’t talking about James’s body or even Adam’s but about a third, hypothetical body, which contained cholesterol plaque rather than a heart and produced seminal fluid rather than come.



              “And if it has spread,” Adam said, “what then?”



              “Well, then we’ll deal with that problem.  It really is an easy surgery, you know.  They remove the prostate in what are called ‘frozen sections,’ making biopsies as they go.”  James had a deep and longstanding appreciation of advancements made by the medical profession, even though he himself had practiced psychology and knew nothing of the human anatomy.  “If it hasn’t spread beyond the prostate itself, then they take it out and I survive.”



              “Listen, dad, I’ll be on the next bus to Sweet Haven.”



              “You will not come home for this.  In two weeks, when I’m all better, Liz and I will come to Montreal, like we planned.  That’s when I want to see you, and not before.  What’s going on here is not really life-threatening surgery.”



              “Are you sure?  I would come down in a heartbeat.”



              “I’m sure,” James said.  His voice sounded confident, comfortable.



              “I love you, dad.  Can’t wait to see you in a few weeks.”



              “Love you too, champ.  Thank you for calling.”



              James put the phone back in the breast pocket of his sport jacket, along with his money clip and his two-by-two-inch leather book of photographs.  It was only six in the evening, still too early to go to the bar for a drink, and so he spent an hour rearranging furniture in the small office that he’d made for himself in the back room of his house.  He switched the Matisse collage with the print of Paul Klee, then switched them back.  He gave the squat Moroccan cushion a kick with the tip of his shoe, to move it further from the armchair, then sat down on the floor with his back against the wall and put his head in his hands and wept inconsolably for half an hour, brushing the tears away roughly, angrily, with the heels of his hands.



              At this moment, James wanted nothing more deeply than the company of his son Adam.  How truly stupid he had been on the phone a moment ago.  If he died in surgery, and Adam heard of it over the phone from Elizabeth, what then?  To what end would he have prevented his only son from returning to Sweet Haven to see him through departure on what might be his final journey into anesthesia?  Yet if he made it through alright, and really did come to Montreal in only three weeks’ time, how proud he would feel to have exhibited such bravery and composure before his wife and son!



              Inside his the closet hung a full-length mirror.  Now he rose and went to it and lifted up his shirt.  A thicket of black and white hairs sprung into view.  He had seen the diagrams in Dr. Blumenthal’s office; he knew that four inches back from the root of his penis cells were dividing maniacally at fantastic, exponential rates.  Hating his body, and frightened of it, he had the urge to reach his hand through his stomach and rip the bloody red gland out with his fist.  James wondered whether every sick man felt this way about the horrible organ which was the source of his affliction, and it occurred to him that surgery was simply the realization of the desire to bite off the trapped paw, to rip out the failing liver or lung or kidney and once more be uncontaminated by disease.



              Inside his desk drawer, his copy of *Anna Karenina* waited for him.  He had only made it half-way through before giving up, but he remembered a particular passage which he had been wanting to consult since first hearing the diagnosis.  James took it out and flipped to page 461:



He knew that for this, for the very fact that his heart was torn with grief, they would be merciless to him.  He felt that men would crush him as dogs strangle a torn dog yelping with pain. He knew that his sole means of security against people was to hide his wounds from them, and instinctively he tried to do this for two days, but now he felt incapable of keeping up the unequal struggle.



              This had struck James hard.  He agreed with Tolstoy when he said, “His sole means of security against people was to hide his wounds from them,” but then he disagreed when he said, “He felt incapable of keeping up the unequal struggle.”  Wasn’t everyone hiding their wounds from everyone else?  What was so goddamn unequal about it?



              Even thinking rationally like this calmed him.  There were other things in his office as well which took his mind off his traitorous prostate.  For instance: the keys to Adam’s 26th birthday gift lay in the drawer next to Anna Karenina.  A strong, beautiful stallion emblazoned the head of the silver key, and in James’s garage the red 1967 Mustang awaited its hour.  He’d found it online for only $19,700 – not too bad now that Elizabeth’s restaurant was doing well.  For months he’d spent afternoons with the car, redoing the paint job entirely by himself and fixing the roof and cleaning the engine.  Nearly every day he considered keeping the car for himself, but a Mustang in the hands of a young man who was just starting out was a powerful thing.  He wanted Adam to have it, with no strings attached, and be free.



 



              When he came home from his walk,  Elizabeth was waiting for him in the kitchen, holding a cup of coffee with two hands.



              “Adam called me today,” he said.  “I told him that I didn’t want him to come home.”



              “I think you’re being silly,” she said, “but if that’s what you want…”



              “What I’m afraid of is that when I’m in surgery they will find cancer cells on the surface,” he said.  “Then I’ll wake up and hear the bad news.  It sounds as though that hormone therapy is really a death sentence.  He said that some people decide to do nothing, they just do ‘watchful waiting.’  There’s a euphemism if I ever heard one.”



              “Either way, I will be there next to you when you wake up.”



              “I think the surgery is the best thing.  Radiation has too many side effects.  I’m old fashioned, Liz; I said to him, ‘Let’s just go in and get it out.’”



              “That’s what I would do too, honey,” she said.  



              “Do you want to eat something?  I made a roast chicken.”



              When they had eaten, and finished a bottle of wine between them, James and Elizabeth went upstairs to the bedroom.  That night they made love as though it were the last time.  It would really be a shame, he thought, never to feel this way again.



              On Wednesday morning Elizabeth woke him up at four and drove him to the hospital.  He was hungry, because the doctors had prohibited him from eating dinner on Tuesday, and he sat upright in the passenger seat with his hands in his lap, trying to keep his breathing even.  What happened next he would remember only in shreds, in the feeling of the blue gown tied around his back and the look of the florescent lights above him when the anesthesiologist administered the shot.  Then nothing.  The operation would take four hours.



              When he came to his mouth was dry, and he asked for a glass of water.  Elizabeth was there, smiling.  “Everything is fine,” she said.  “They got it all.”



              But everything was not fine.  Though he may have been, as Dr. Blumenthal told him, a very lucky man, he had not escaped prostate cancer entirely unscathed.  The in-surgery biopsies had revealed cancer cells dangerously close to the surface of the prostate, and the urologist had decided to remove both neurovascular bundles rather than only one, as they had discussed before the operation.  James Loveland would be impotent from now on.  “Both?” he said.  He was still groggy from the anesthesia but his eyes sprung open and he drew a hard breath.  He could barely get it out: “More water, please.  Cold water, if you have it.”  But he was thinking: no, no, no, no, please, no.



 



              What is there to do in a hospital bed, such as the one in which James found himself for three days after his surgery, when you’ve turned the lights out for the night?  What is there to do if you can’t sleep?  If, even when you can, your terrible dream comes back, same as it was when you were a young man?  James Loveland woke at 2, 3, 4, 5 a.m., furious with himself for arriving late and missing the train.  It took him a moment, whenever he woke up, to remember where he was and why he was there.  It took him a moment to remember that he would never know what sex was like again.  What would he have done differently if he’d known that sixty-six was to be his unlucky year?



              James tried to remember the women he’d slept with as a young man.  The list with pitifully small, and he found it difficult to retrieve details -- particular beds, bodies, smells.  He’d always assumed he would have more.



 



II



              In November, Adam went to visit his father.  It really was an incredible inconvenience; Zoe, his girlfriend, hadn’t wanted him to come.  



              The taxi shivered up the driveway, crunching down leaves from the oak, elm, dogwood, beech and maple.  He slammed the door and shouldered his overnight bag, then walked up the curving brick path to the front door.  It was after ten in the evening.  He pressed the gold button.  From inside its white plastic housing on the kitchen wall, the electric doorbell rang.  It had been one of Adam’s first lessons in carpentry and electronics to replace, as an eight-year-old boy, the family’s old tube-and-hammer doorbell with a speaker box.



              A moment later, light spilled from the old iron fixture beside the door.  James always turned the outdoor light on first, in part because he liked to identify his guests before being identified himself, and in part because he mistakenly considered it a courtesy to blast them with light while the vestibule was still in darkness.  Adam imagined him standing in his slippered feet on the cold blue tile of the vestibule, cinching his robe more tightly around his waist.  “Coming!” he called from inside.  More lights came on.  “Coming.”  His voice was louder now, and the deadbolt burrowed into the side of the door.  Adam was determined to stay only one day.  He knew that if he lingered in Sweet Have too long, he might return to Montreal and find Zoë gone.  His father’s voice called again.  “Adam Sidney?”



              “Hi, dad.”



              It opened.  “Adam!”  His father’s arms had some of the old strength back, Adam could feel it when they embraced.  “Boy, it’s cold out here.  Come inside.  I’ll make you a drink.”



              The house was cold, too, because James, to save money, refused to run the heat higher than was absolutely necessary for the survival of biological organisms.  It seemed to Adam that a man recovering from cancer might want his house heated to a reasonable temperature in autumn, but he resolved to say nothing; it had been six years since he’d lived in Sweet Haven—it was time to let the setting on the thermostat go unremarked.



              “Why don’t we visit in the kitchen,” James said.  “It’s cozy in there.”



              “Is mom home?”



              “She’s at work.  What would you like?  I’m having bourbon.”



              “Bourbon’s fine.”



              “We have so much to talk about!  Here; I know you take ice.  Sit down.  So, tell me what’s up.”  James pronounced “what’s up” as two separate words.



              “Dad.  I’m sorry we didn’t have much time together in Montreal.  Is everything okay?  It’s only been two months since the surgery.”



               His father shifted in his seat.  “That long?  It feels like ages ago now.”



              Neither man wanted to laugh; both laughed.



              “Not ages, dad, only a little while.  What do the doctors say?”



              “Well Blumenthal refuses to say I’m cured, you see, he says we need to wait years to be certain.  But I feel fine.  Everything works almost like normal.  Lizzie told you about what happened, I bet.”



              “Mom didn’t tell me anything.”



              “Of course she didn’t,” James said.  The kitchen windows were black mirrors; Adam could see himself, holding his drink, reflected above his father’s head.



              “What’s wrong?  Did it spread?”



              “No, no, no, no.  They got it all.”  His father shivered underneath his robe.  It was too much for Adam: “Will you please turn the heat up, dad?  If you don’t turn the fucking heat on then I’m going to leave.”  Then, thinking his father might be more likely to act if he could preserve his dignity, he added: “I’m really getting cold.”



              James shuffled across the room and turned the dial reluctantly to the right.  In the basement, the furnace gasped.  Then, rather than return to the table, he busied himself with an unnecessary inspection of the thermostat while he said, “They took out both neurovascular bundles.  My”—he paused, looking for words, facing away from Adam—“my evening schedule has been considerably freed up.”  James looked up from the thermostat.  “It may take a few minutes before we get the benefit of it,” he said.  “Would you like to make a fire with me?  The living room can be much cozier with a good fire going.”



              “Sure.  Let’s make a fire.”



              “We have plenty of kindling,” said James, leading the way to the living room.



              When they had it burning, they sat close to the wire screen.  Adam was gratified to see that his father no longer shivered.  “I’m sorry, dad,” he said.



              “Me too.  It’s a hell of a thing.”  He repeated, more to himself than to Adam: “A hell of a thing.”



              “What time will mom be home?”  



              “She may be out late tonight,” said James.  “But hey—now that you’re warm, I have something to show you.  Something to give you.”  He rubbed his hands together with eagerness, got up from the couch and left the room.  So his own father—the father whose genes he carried—couldn’t make love.  And now his mother was out at work?  At 1am?  Then James’s quick, slippered steps.



              “This is something I’ve been working on for a long time.  I know your birthday is still two weeks away, but who knows if you’ll be home for it, so tonight’s the night.”  From across the room, he tossed Adam a small black box.  Adam caught it in one hand.  “Open it,” he said.  



              It was a silver key with a stallion on the head.  “Come.  I’ll show you what it does.”  The garage was separated from the house by a small cobblestone path, which, like the driveway, lay under leaves.  “Wait here,” said James, and raised up the overhead door.  A shining red Mustang—probably 1966 or ’67—crouched in the dim light.  “It’s for you.  Isn’t it something?  I’ve been restoring it.  Start it up: listen to it!”



              Adam had never owned a car before.  When he turned the key, it purred beautifully.  



              “Dad, this is incredible!  I can’t believe you did this.”



              James was obviously pleased.  “You see?” he said.  “You can go anywhere.  And this way you can come and visit me anytime you want.  If you want, that is.  No buses, no planes—you just get in and go.  It’s a beautiful drive through New Hampshire if you cut through the White Mountain pass.”



              “I’m sure it is,” said Adam.  “We’ll have to go out in it sometime.”



              “I thought tomorrow we could take a drive.”



              “Tomorrow I can’t; I really have to get back to Zoë.  I only meant to come for a night, to make sure you were doing okay.”



              If James was hurt, he hid it well.  “Yes, go back, definitely.  Another time.  And by the way: when you do go back, give this to Zoë.  She’ll like it.”  It was a photograph of him as a baby, which he had seen a thousand times, blown up the size of a postcard.  “You want me to give Zoë a photo of myself?”



              “Trust me,” said James.  “She’ll love it.”



              “Dad, are you sure you feel well?  If mom isn’t going to be around that much, maybe you should get someone to come in once in a while.  To clean up and all that.”



              “I’m only sixty-six years old, Adam,” James said.  “I’m not dead yet.  So tell me more about Zoë.”



              Adam told his father.  It took a long time to explain everything; at four in the morning they were still going, talking and drinking together as though they were brothers.  They stayed up until Elizabeth’s car came up the drive.  Then they went upstairs and said goodnight, like brothers do.



              Adam knew that his lover would be there for him when he got back to Montreal.  



 



 



Features Winter 2020 - Feast




*C Pam Zhang is a fiction writer whose stories have appeared in McSweeney’s Quarterly Concern, American Short Fiction, the Kenyon Review, and elsewhere. Her debut novel, How Much of These Hills is Gold, is forthcoming from Riverhead Books in April 2020. The Fiction Board caught up with her over email to ask a few questions about writing, revising, and feasting.*



**What is your novel about, and what inspired it? When did you start writing your first draft, and what approach did you take to writing and revising?**



My novel is reimagining of the myth of the American West that centers, instead of white men, two children of immigrants who set out with the body of their dead father. It’s about home, grief, tigers and buffalos, mourning for a ravaged land. The kernel at its heart may be this question: what is it like to live with the visceral reality of a dead body?



I had no intention of writing this novel. I woke up with the first images in my head and exorcised them in the form of a short story. Then I tried to avoid the project because, let’s be honest: why would anyone willingly embark on a novel? It is so long, so thankless, so grueling. You can’t want to write a novel; it must be a need, a hounding.



I wrote my first draft quickly because I believe the goal of any first draft is to produce a heap of utter trash. That’s it. Nothing loftier. That’s the only way you’ll get through it without self-sabotaging by way of perfectionism. When you see your first draft as joyous garbage, it becomes much easier to throw great swathes away in revision, which is the real work of the novel. Probably ten percent of that first draft made it into the final draft; the finished novel is draft maybe, I don’t know, twenty?



**Which books or authors have had the biggest influence on your writing? I’m wondering, for instance, whether the journey your characters take to bury their father is meant to be a spin on *As I Lay Dying*? Are you intentional about situating your work within particular genres (e.g., Asian American literature, immigrant literature, historical fiction, magical realism)?**



I have never read *As I Lay Dying*! In fact I’ve never read Faulkner, or Joyce, or a dozen other writers in the supposed canon, and that’s okay. I mention this only because I used to be ashamed, especially in collegiate settings where I assumed everyone was much more learned than me. I unlearned shame fairly recently. Make your own canon.



I love Marilyn Chin’s *Tales of the Mooncake Vixen* for how she plays with, cannibalizes, thumbs her nose at, mythology. Toni Morrison’s *Beloved* because she is a genius, and makes language and memory ferociously her own. Larry McMurtry’s *Lonesome Dove* for that classic Western epic. Annie Proulx’s *The Shipping News* for language as engine, as joy even when the topic itself is bleak.



Even to this day I get queasy when I see my novel filed under any genre—historical, Asian American, what have you. Genre designations are for readers and marketplaces. They’re not for the writer to consider when writing. They’ll only stifle you if you think about them too early.



**Who are your first readers? Are you friends with other writers? If so, how have you met them?**



I met quite a few of my writing friends online, where we exchange work and also lots of anxiety about writing. Highly recommended to have friends with whom you can be free about your never-ending anxiety.



**When did you start working with your agent and editor? Did anything surprise you about the process of finding and collaborating with them?**



I worked with them very late! Not until I was several drafts into my novel and had polished it as much as I could by myself. The writer Lauren Groff once gave me this excellent advice: if you consider yourself married to your novel, don’t send it out until you’re ready to divorce it. It wasn’t that I thought my novel was perfect when I looked for an agent; it was that I could see a million ways to change it and I no longer had a sense of what change would be for the better or for the worse. I was sick and tired of its stupid face.



I was most surprised by how much I loved being edited. I’d heard before that some writers dislike being edited, and can only conclude that perhaps there are bad editors out there. Both my editor and agent ask questions that force me to think more deeply, rather than give prescriptive feedback. There is a level of foundational trust that they earned at the beginning by speaking about my novel in terms that resonated with me. If anyone ever describes your novel in a way that makes you cringe or gives you pause, that is not your person, no matter how powerful or esteemed.



**The first story I read of yours was “Dad.Me” in McSweeney’s 53, which according to your Twitter “was rejected 38 freakin’ times.” As a writer, how do you deal with rejection? How do you know a story is worth working on and submitting even after it’s been rejected repeatedly?**



I was once told that a writer needs two things: an enormous ego and crippling self-doubt. They’re uneasy partners in this strange writing life. The enormous ego gets you through to the end of projects; the crippling self-doubt helps you edit and be a decent human in the world.



There are plenty of stories I’ve thrown away after a few rejections, or sometimes just a tactful comment from a trusted reader. I kept submitting “Dad.Me” because, quite simply, it moved me every time I read it. Pay attention to when your own work moves you, really moves you—and I don’t mean when it impresses you, or you think you’ve written an especially lyrical metaphor.



**You studied English as an undergrad at Brown. How do you think reading in an academic or critical context differs from reading as a fiction writer? I’ve heard from some writers that studying and analyzing English literature can stifle the creative impulse, whereas other writers find that literary studies and creative writing can be mutually productive. What was your experience?**



There can be great pleasure and satisfaction in an academic paper: the pleasure of articulation. The ability to articulate why you love what you love—or why you hate what you hate—is a tool all people, really, should have.



That said, articulation is a tool for readers and editors; don’t pick it up to write with.



**What kinds of day jobs have you had since graduating from college, and how have they affected your writing or your ability to write?**



I have always had a day job or freelance work. Straight out of college I worked in the San Francisco tech scene full time for about two years, then transitioning to part time. I still do tech work. I grew up in a low-income immigrant family and don’t have a safety net to fall back on. There is no shame in having a career that financially supports you—so many writers have either that or a familial safety net or a romantic partner who pays a greater share of living expenses, and it is criminal that we aren’t more vocal about that.



The hard truth is we do not live in a country that supports artists. Full stop. Support yourself, and be smart about it.



Remember that writing requires both the time to write and the mental freedom to do so. I did not have the latter if I lived in a state of precarity, worried about my next paycheck, how to make rent. Find a balance. Be steely-eyed about what you go into your paying job for, and therefore how much of yourself to put into the job. But it is very possible!



**Finally, an obligatory *FEAST* question —— having lived in thirteen cities across four countries, what are some of your favorite foods and/or eateries that you associate with different places?**



Providence, Rhode Island is cheap deals on buffalo wing deals. Bangkok, Thailand is fried fish from the street, where they get their residual warmth comes from sitting all day under the sun. Union City, California is greasy Chinese food at homestyle restaurants with every item on the menu plastered on the wall. Cambridge, UK is chip butties and Sainbury’s basics.


THE HARVARD ADVOCATE
21 South Street
Cambridge, MA 02138
president@theharvardadvocate.com